Update Scoringmodel.md

This commit is contained in:
Mykola Siusko 2023-02-07 23:06:30 +01:00 odevzdal GitHub
rodič 7423f64f61
revize c8465a9f85
V databázi nebyl nalezen žádný známý klíč pro tento podpis
ID GPG klíče: 4AEE18F83AFDEB23
1 změnil soubory, kde provedl 22 přidání a 19 odebrání

Zobrazit soubor

@ -165,16 +165,17 @@ I asked experts behind privacy-services or contributors to the privacy-centric c
| DAO structure (if applied) | - | + |
# Privacy execution
- How is it being transmitted? (encrypted, unencrypted, offuscated, etc)
- Confidentiality of transactions
- the ability to hide transactional data from the public
- strong encryption algorithms
- If the speed in connection is too fast, there most probably no privacy there and rather a direct channel between user - app
- p2p / no central server
- Reliant on one encryption method or multiple
- Combined those encryption methods effectively (holistic solution)
- Trustless - No ID required (this is where ZKs are useful)
- Usage of ZK
| Scoring | Non-web3 person assesment | Non-tech assesment |
| ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| How is it being transmitted? (encrypted, unencrypted, offuscated, etc) | - | - |
| Combined those encryption methods effectively (holistic solution) | - | - |
| Confidentiality of transactions | - | - |
| the ability to hide transactional data from the public | - | - |
| strong encryption algorithms | - | - |
| If the speed in connection is too fast, there most probably no privacy there and rather a direct channel between user - app | - | - |
| p2p / no central server | - | - |
| Trustless - No ID required (this is where ZKs are useful) | - | + |
| Usage of ZK | - | - |
# Product-centric
| Scoring | Non-web3 person assesment | Non-tech assesment |
@ -191,15 +192,17 @@ I asked experts behind privacy-services or contributors to the privacy-centric c
| Other tooling to verify e.g. block explorers | - | + |
# Other
- Entropy (non-trivial to estimate, different measurements for type of service). Some examples: https://arxiv.org/abs/2211.04259 or https://blog.nymtech.net/an-empirical-study-of-privacy-scalability-and-latency-of-nym-mixnet-ff05320fb62d
- Censorship-resistant (how hard it's for a powerful party to block/censor a given service)
- Precise description of the concrete privacy properties. Privacy is complicated, so if they don't say exactly what they protect, then its likely vapour
- Doesnt sell your data
- protects against a global passive adversary
- strong secure anonymity tech
- Credibly neutral
- ISO/IEC 29190:2015: https://www.iso.org/standard/45269.html
- Anonymity Assessment – A Universal Tool for Measuring Anonymity of Data Sets Under the GDPR with a Special Focus on Smart Robotics: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3971139
| Scoring | Non-web3 person assesment | Non-tech assesment |
| ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| Entropy (non-trivial to estimate, different measurements for type of service). Some examples: https://arxiv.org/abs/2211.04259 or https://blog.nymtech.net/an-empirical-study-of-privacy-scalability-and-latency-of-nym-mixnet-ff05320fb62d | - | - |
| Censorship-resistant (how hard it's for a powerful party to block/censor a given service) | - | - |
| Precise description of the concrete privacy properties. Privacy is complicated, so if they don't say exactly what they protect, then its likely vapour | - | - |
| Doesnt sell your data | - | - |
| protects against a global passive adversary | - | - |
| strong secure anonymity tech | - | - |
| Credibly neutral | + | + |
| ISO/IEC 29190:2015: https://www.iso.org/standard/45269.html | - | - |
| Anonymity Assessment – A Universal Tool for Measuring Anonymity of Data Sets Under the GDPR with a Special Focus on Smart Robotics: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3971139 | - | - |
_Huge thanks everyone who contributed! I make it anon now, but will thank everyone (who would liked to be credited) once a scoring model will be published on GitHub for community evaluation._